Five Questions for Paul Bertolino

Interviewed by Justin Nash

The only child of immigrant parents, and 35-year veteran of the US Postal Service, Rev.Paul Bertolino became a Christian when he was 27-years old at a Crusade for Christ event in 1963.  He had a strong desire to learn all he could about this new relationship with Christ, so he enrolled in the Boston Evening School of the Bible, sponsored by Park Street Church in Boston, and took as many courses as he could. The ministry that immediately caught his heart was working with the high school youth.

Starting with three young people in his youth group, the Fishermen Gospel Team was formed.  This team grew to more than 75 young people from all denominations, and they traveled all across New England and as far west as Chicago, sharing the good news of the gospel. The group was comprised of several teams, e.g. drama, skits, music, puppets, etc. This ministry allowed Pastor Bertolino to develop his teaching/preaching skills, train and mentor young people and adults and was a catalyst for his need to share the gospel with others.  

In the early 70s he was approached by a deacon from the Haverhill, Mass. Advent Christian Church to supply preach on a Sunday morning.  This was an inner-city church, surrounded by apartments housing drunks and drug addicts, that had dwindled in size and the church leadership was seriously considering a possible closure. They had already called 28 men and each one had declined for different reasons. When the latest candidate refused their offer, they asked if Rev. Bertolino would consider coming as their pastor. After prayer and godly counsel, his wife and he agreed to come with one stipulation:  he would not leave his postal position. When he left eight years later, the church had won a denominational contest for the fastest-growing Sunday school, had planted a new church, mentored several pastoral students from Gordon-Conwell Seminary who went on to become Advent Christian pastors and the church had developed seven staff members.

In the later 80s, he was asked to pastor a small Baptist church. This little country church had only six people attending when he arrived. Again, he connected with Gordon-Conwell to mentor pastoral students. He worked with some fine young men, two of whom have been Advent Christian pastors all of their years of service.  

In the 90s he retired from the USPS and went to serve at the Meredith, N.H. Advent Christian church. This was the first time he had only one job! In 2007, he found himself truly retired and living at Advent Christian Village. He pastored a small church nearby for more than three years.  When he arrived there were a handful of people, but the church peaked at more than 80. Pastor Bertolino also mentored a young pastor that serves as an Advent Christian pastor today. He is now ministering at the Village Church as an elder and a Sunday school teacher.   

A pastor should not have a Lone Ranger approach - even the Lone Ranger had Tonto!

What's the one big thing you got right?

PB: Maybe a couple of things. Asking Jesus to come into my life and forgive my sins and asking Barbara to marry me. Also, investing in people in order to build a team ministry. Foundational Scriptures for this approach include Ephesians 4:11-13, 2 Timothy 2:2, Matthew 28:18-20, Acts 1:8 and Exodus 18. I am an ordinary man; there are others who have gifts far beyond what I have. My job as a pastor was to discover who they were, how they were gifted and train them. A pastor should not have a Lone Ranger approach – even the Lone Ranger had Tonto!

What's the one big thing you got wrong?

PB: Being bi-vocational has some advantages. It allows you the ability to work in a small church that cannot afford a pastoral salary. It keeps you in the world where you rub shoulders with others who need to know Jesus. It helps your church members to relate to you. But a drawback is a severe lack of time; time alone to regenerate and time spent with family. I wish I had guarded my day off more carefully.

What brings you the most joy in ministry?

PB: Bottom line: seeing people come to Christ. And that can happen anytime, anywhere, with anyone. Some of my fondest memories are praying the sinner’s prayer with people who lived on my mail delivery route!  Also, watching those you invested in now working in ministry. Two years ago we had a reunion at Alton Bay with those young people I worked with in the 60s.  More than 50 people showed up and all were still following Jesus and active in their local church! 

What advice would you give someone in a situation similar to yours?

First, use the Scripture as the standard for living, teaching and preaching. Second, protect your family time and personal time from unnecessary intrusions. Third, seek and develop the spiritual gifts and talents that lie within each of your church members.

PB: First, use the Scripture as the standard for living, teaching and preaching. Second, protect your family time and personal time from unnecessary intrusions. Third, seek and develop the spiritual gifts and talents that lie within each of your church members.

What is the one thing you wish you were better at as a pastor?

PB: In ministry I had a difficult time saying “No.” And I still work hard at being able to relax; I always feel as if I must be “doing something”!  A good verse for me to keep reminding myself is Psalm 46:10, “Be still (relax) and know that I am God.”

Justin Nash, “Five Questions for Paul Bertolino” The Witness, Summer 2020